
How should the business model be assessed for a stablecoin classified as a financial asset?
A French group uses separate stablecoin portfolios for settlement and trading. The consolidation team should document how each portfolio is managed before proposing its IFRS 9 classification. Financial-asset scope is an established assumption for this analysis, rather than a conclusion drawn from the token’s name. The analysis concerns the group’s IFRS reporting.
Identify where management decisions are made
IFRS 9, paragraphs B4.1.1–B4.1.2B, requires a collective assessment: portfolio objectives, reports to key management, risk management and managers’ remuneration. An intention for one token is insufficient. Collecting contractual cash flows, selling assets or combining the two describes how cash flows are generated. This business model assessment is separate from the contractual cash flow characteristics test covered in the SPPI article.
For the reporting close, obtain the treasury report actually submitted to management and reconcile it with the investment mandate. Where a report combines two activities, establish who decides for each activity and how performance is tracked. Separate wallet names alone do not demonstrate separate management practices.

Trace redemption and sale separately
Hypothetical case: management separately monitors portfolio A, holding 200,000 euro-referenced tokens, and portfolio B, holding 50,000. These amounts illustrate the working paper and do not describe a client.
For A, treasury describes the purpose as funding supplier payments. The reviewer requests the exit documents: a redemption request to the contractual debtor, confirmation and bank credit, or an executed sale order with a buyer. A “treasury” label does not answer this question. Reconstruct exits during the period and explain differences between the mandate and actual transactions.
For B, the committee receives a weekly arbitrage result and approves purchases and sales within specific limits. Retain minutes, performance reports and dealing instructions. Those documents support examining a different management approach from A, without inferring the accounting category from the holdings’ size. This documentary approach is BECTRA’s practical analysis of the case.

Explain sales and connect both assessments
Paragraphs B4.1.2C–B4.1.6 require sales to be considered in context; one sale does not settle the assessment. A model combining collection and sale requires both activities to contribute to its objective. Fair-value-based management calls for a different analysis. The business model alone does not establish amortised cost or FVOCI: the other IFRS 9 conditions, including SPPI, still need to be assessed.
For A, attach a dated explanation, approver and settlement documents to each significant sale. For B, reconcile committee reports with executed orders. The consolidation lead can then propose a conclusion for each portfolio and raise contradictory evidence with the reviewer before the close.
Conclusion
The BECTRA deliverable is a portfolio assessment sheet recording scope, observed objective, decision owner, reporting, monitored risks, documented exits and the proposed conclusion, with references to supporting records. It gives the group and reviewer a traceable basis for classification. French statutory accounts require their own analysis; this working paper addresses IFRS reporting.
Further reading




Comments